SuperVegan Logo

As of October, 2013, SuperVegan is no longer under active development.
The site content remains online in the interest of history.

We are still active on Twitter:

To keep informed about future projects of SuperVegan, join the SuperVegan Projects mailing list:

The Amazing Instant New York City Vegan Restaurant Finder


 Either within

How Vegan should the restaurant be?

(check all that apply)

Want more options? Try our mildly overwhelming advanced search page.


 the entire site:

NYC Metro Area Vegan Restaurant Graveyard

Cowgirl's Baking

Food: 3.23.2
Atmosphere: 3.23.2
Service: 3.63.6

(5 shared memories. Leave your own!)

Map loading... If this message persists, your browser is not capable of displaying our maps.

259 East 10th Street
New York   NY 10009
View this restaurant's page on other sites:

This restaurant is closed. Share your memories of other restaurants past at SuperVegan's NYC Metro Area Vegan Restaurant Graveyard.

Veg level:

100% Vegan

Price Range:

$$$$$ (Average entree cost: $5-$10)

Accepted Payments:

  • Visa
  • ·
  • Mastercard


Daily: 11am-8pm

Delivery notes:

Cowgirl's Baking delivered.

Free delivery on purchases over $15 to locations within the delivery zone between Houston Street & 23rd Street and between 6th Avenue & East River Drive.Delivery Map


All-vegan bakery offering a rotating menu of: house-made cookies, cupcakes, donuts, cakes, croissants, scones, muffins, sticky buns, pie, tiramisu, pudding, funnel cakes, churros, truffles, brownies, cannolis and a few savory sandwiches, salads, burritos, and snacks.
Check their Twitter page for the daily selection

Bookmark and Share The information on this page was last updated on November 1, 2011.

Shared Memories of Cowgirl's Baking

Averaged user ratings:

(1 star = lousy; 5 stars = great)
Food: 3.23.2
Atmosphere: 3.23.2
Service: 3.63.6
  • Review by champurrado on May 24, 2011:

  • The burritos are so salty they're inedible. None of us could finish ours (which is crazy--we never do that!). Desserts are better but also strangely salty. Basically everything is done super cheaply. Sandwiches are store-bought wonder bread style slices with tofutti cheese slices and some meat analogue. Burritos use TVP soaked in gross salty broth for all the 'meat' fillings. TVP chunks and tofutti slices are just not really acceptable for a vegan restaurant in NYC in 2011. I'm really hoping they're able to step it up with higher quality ingredients as they have more success. In the mean time, I'd recommend buying the sweets but skipping the other stuff.
  • Food: 11
    Atmosphere: 33
    Service: 33
  • Review by lucifly on May 19, 2011:

  • Yummy treats and food. I really like the atmosphere! & they made a special sandwhich for me when what I wanted wasn't on the menu
  • Food: 55
    Atmosphere: 55
    Service: 55
  • Review by karla_marx on May 18, 2011:

  • I have been here twice, just to pick up desserts to go, and I have been thoroughly impressed each time! Today I got some doughnuts and my friend and I were amazed at the perfect texture. Just like the last non-vegan doughnut I had in 1996. Okay, it's been a while, but this was a great vegan doughnut.

    I've never tried the savory food, but the cupcakes, cookies, tarts, and doughnuts have always been wonderful. There's not much atmosphere of which to speak, but I have had great service and conversation with the owner each time I went.
  • Food: 55
    Atmosphere: 33
    Service: 55
  • Review by bootpants on May 17, 2011:

  • I was super excited when Livingsocial had a deal. Pay $10, get $20 worth of food! I bought cupcakes, pretzel sticks dipped in chocolate, a donut... None of it was particularly amazing. I only finished the chocolate cupcake. Everything else I threw out after one bite. The pretzel sticks were stale, the chocolate white (old). I was very disappointed and will most likely not return soon.

    The staff seemed bored and didn't really care. The atmosphere was strange: Random burrito bar in the corner, hand-written posterboards for menus, no signage on baked goods, so I had to guess what everything was...

    I think as a vegan place you have to try even harder to be amazing, so you can win non-vegans over. This place clearly needs to work on that.
  • Food: 22
    Atmosphere: 22
    Service: 22
  • Review by beanmail on May 12, 2011:

  • So disappointed; I've gone here twice so far and have not been impressed.

    The owner doesn't seem to smile, the staff seems bored, and the stuff I've tried has been so-so, bordering on "what people think vegan food tastes like".

    Eventually I'll return; hopefully I'll have my mind changed. But for now? Nope. Too many other fantastic places around.
  • Food: 33
    Atmosphere: 33
    Service: 33

Restaurant reviews are temporarily closed. We look forward to accepting your reviews again soon!